The Asj Community
The Dom's Lounge
share their thoughts
Asj submissive slave register
keywords: A submissives journey,spanking,
sensual spanking, BDSM, submissive, bottom, aftercare, slave training,
has many meanings. The literal meaning was taken from the word disciple,
meaning, "a follower, one who takes another as a teacher [therefore, if she is
your disciple, then you will teach her (discipline her)]."
The definition of discipline I use is: "Training intended to produce a specified
character or pattern of behavior." And when training is complete, this third
definition of discipline is what you have; "a state of order based on submission
to rules and authority."
I have noticed that in chat most people seem to believe that discipline is the
same as punishment. In my opinion, the main difference between discipline and
punishment is that discipline uses training methods that closely correlate to
the misbehavior, whereas punishment is arbitrary, involves no training methods,
and does not have to 'fit the crime.'
I assume this other view of discipline is based on this fourth definition of
discipline: "punishment intended to correct or train." This, I believe, is an
acceptable use of the word discipline if one is thinking of having a submissive
stick her tongue to a bar of soap to curb her bad language. If this is done when
the bad language is uttered, this form of punishment could be said to correct or
If, however, the punishment for bad language is a spanking, since there is no
correlation to the misbehavior and the punishment used to correct it, it is not
training nor correction. If we substitute the word punishment for discipline,
then this makes more sense.
Punishment is a "penalty for wrongdoing." It does not necessarily have to fit
the crime. Punishment can be arbitrary, determined by whim. A Dominant can
impose any punishment he chooses for any misbehavior (although this needs to be
set forth from the beginning so that the submissive knows what she is risking
with misbehavior). But this is not discipline, it is not used to train the
submissive, it is used to punish her.
Let me offer an example of discipline and then some of punishment to illustrate
my point. Suppose you want your submissive to focus more on your sexual needs
than her own. You wouldn't spank her for being aroused would you? Would you send
her to the corner for being horny? Of course you wouldn't, not if your goal is
to train her to focus her sexual energy into meeting your sexual needs and not
A method I would suggest is positive reinforcement. When she is aroused and
thinking of her own sexual needs you would have her pleasure you in some sexual
manner. She is not allowed orgasm; her pleasure will come in the form of her
satisfying her need to please you.
You can tease her a bit, get a little rough with her, and keep her excited by
your comments or expressions of pleasure (this will satisfy her need to be
controlled). After you are satisfied, be affectionate with her. Tell her what a
wonderful "girl" she is, and how much she has pleased you. Snuggle her close to
you and fall asleep this way (this will meet her needs to feel special and cared
for). In this way, she will eventually feel her sexual arousal as a need to
worship your body. This is discipline (training).
Punishment will make her feel bad about herself, afraid of you, or resentful.
Now that I have made some people angry, let me say that I understand that this
may not be what you intend to use it for, but this is the effect.
An example of punishment might be spanking your submissive because she used
unacceptable language. Now remember this is punishment, not S/m play, this
cannot be fun for either of you for it to be real punishment.
It must not be something she likes (does she like being spanked? If she does,
this is not punishment, it is play). If this is something either of you likes,
you are reinforcing the bad behavior rather than curbing it. If she likes being
spanked, she will use this language whenever she wants you to spank her. If she
doesn't like to be spanked, she is now in a position that is teetering on abuse.
We defend our play style and our lifestyle with the Safe, Sane, and Consensual
credo. We do this because we are aware that without consent, the physical
aspects of our play are simply abuse. If the submissive isn't aroused by intense
sensation (sensual pain), then we can not use it, unless she has consented to
Why would someone consent to something she does not like? If she is submissive,
she could very well consent to it to please her dominant, but is it safe and
sane? If she is allowing you to do something to her that she does not like at
all, especially something that causes pain, she is creating a confusing conflict
in her own mind. This conflict is perfect for triggering memories of past pain
and abuse. There is nothing safe or sane about this.
You are putting your submissive in emotional danger by requesting that she
accept physical pain that she does not enjoy. You could easily find yourself
dealing with some serious emotional fallout, possibly so serious, that you will
not be equipped to handle it adequately. Is this risk of emotional pain and
trauma worth it--just because you want to punish her?
Exactly what does punishment do for you or your submissive? How does it benefit
you? The allure, I think, is control; ultimate control. For a dominant to feel
that he has so much control over another human being that he can even strike
this person (and not risk retaliation) to show her disapproval is a heady
But people, this is fantasy stuff. This is like the fantasy of having your
submissive live in a cage in your basement. It is hot, arousing, and fills you
with a feeling of exquisite power, but it is not realistic.
Spanking for mutual pleasure (you can pretend the she is actually being
punished) can be wonderfully fulfilling if you have these fantasies of ultimate
control. They work quite well in scene. They cannot, however, be translated into
reality. Punishing an adult simply does not work.
There is too much mental resistance to it in the adult mind. Even if she
consents to it and means for it to be effective, it rarely 'takes.' The same
punishment is needed again and again and as it continues to be administered,
your submissive becomes more and more emotionally damaged by it. This is not a
loving, mutually uplifting relationship in which each partner grows and becomes
her better self.
Mental punishment is no more effective than physical punishment. Using the
'silent treatment,' pouting, avoidance, and withholding sex all create
resentment or the pain of rejection when used as punishment. These feelings eat
at the foundation of your relationship; they are silent destroyers of love.
These punishments will not alter your partner's behavior because they do not
motivate. Adults change themselves because they are motivated to do so.
Positive reinforcement motivates, negative reinforcement does not. When adults
are confronted with pain or unpleasantness, they simply find ways to avoid this
feeling, even if that means avoiding the person doling out the unpleasantness.
Do you avoid people who nag at you, even if they have your best interests at
heart? If negative reinforcement worked, then firing a person from a job would
motivate him to be a better worker. If negative reinforcement was effective,
when your boss upbraided you in front of your coworkers, you would become a much
more pleasant and productive employee. If it worked, when she gave you the
'silent treatment' because you were late for a date, you would never be late
again. If it worked, you would only need to spank your submissive once.
like the bridle in the hand of a good rider, should exercise its influence
without appearing to do so; should be ever active, both as a support and as a
restraint, yet seem to lie easily in hand. It must always be ready to
check or to pull up, as occasion may require; and only when the horse is a
runaway should the action of the curb be perceptible".
Questions about our site? Click the ask live icon to chat live or leave a
message with our site host. CJ isn't always available, but generally
you can find Him here from about 8:30 - 11:00 pm Eastern time. Your
questions about the site, the Asj community or just about the lifestyle
in general are always welcome. If nothing else, take a moment and tell
us what you think of this feature!
books for Dom's,,,
Copyright © 2002 - 2010 [A submissives journey]. All rights reserved.
October 16, 2011